Mc Naught & Co
News

Are Mothers’ rights more equal than Fathers’?

Parental Responsibilities and Rights are under the spotlight today. The Children’s Act 38 of 2005 has attempted to focus our society and courts’ attention on the interests of the child which are paramount in any custody or contact dispute between parents.

 

Often the parties hide behind the blanket phrase the “best interests of the child” to give their own twisted interpretation as to what would be best. Fathers’ rights have traditionally been disregarded in favour of the mother, and children have frequently been pawns in a battle between the parents.

 

In recent years the concept of “parental alienation” has come to the fore as South Africa’s divorced and unmarried fathers have had to battle to maintain contact with their children, or to have contact at all.

 

Professor Weshal Domingo, the head of law at Wits University and a family law expert, and her colleague, law lecturer Prinslean Mahery, write how, despite South Africa’s Childrens Act framework, which “created a shift from the idea of parental power over a child to the notion that parents have parental responsibilities and rights”, this hasn’t fundamentally changed the constant battle that parents and other interested parties have over children.

 

The “maternal preference and tender years” doctrine has been abandoned by the country’s courts to an extent. The biological father who was either married to the mother, or who has accepted paternity, even though unmarried, has full parental responsibilities and rights.The unmarried father’s right to equality is strengthened and children are seen as having rights to maintain contact with their father.

 

The best interests of the child are however always paramount and in many cases the courts rely on expert evidence to assist in reaching a finding that will serve the bests interests of the children concerned. Sadly many Judges still favour the mother, but more and more are mandating mediation by couples who are caught up in a battle when exercising their parental rights and responsibiities.

 

If you are seeking to draw up a Parental Responsibilities and Rights or Parenting Plan, or require mediation in settling issues of contact or maintenance, Mc Naught and Company can help in this regard.

 

References: The Childrens’ Act 38 of 2005 and The Saturday Star.

Share this article
Now!
Read our
most recent!
Wrongfulness and Legal Duty

Wrongfulness and Legal Duty

A recent judgment was passed in the Supreme Court of Appeal, the facts to the case itself are indeed interesting, especially for pet owners. The claimant in the matter, arranged with her friends for a weekend of leisure at the Harmony Park Resort, a day camp (the Day Camp) situated at Strand in the Western Cape. The Day Camp was a public facility under the control of the defendant, the City of Cape Town.

Read More
SA Divorces up by 20% since Lockdown Level 4

SA Divorces up by 20% since Lockdown Level 4

Courts around South Africa are battling a surprising divorce backlog. This is such a problem that a plan to fast-track annulments of more than 11 000 failed marriages in Limpopo alone has had to be devised. Limpopo is not the only province with a heavy load of divorce applications. The South Gauteng High Court heard 33 unopposed divorces last Friday.

Read More
Are Mothers’ rights more equal than Fathers’?

Are Mothers’ rights more equal than Fathers’?

Parental Responsibilities and Rights are under the spotlight today. The Children’s Act 38 of 2005 has attempted to focus our society and courts’ attention on the interests of the child which are paramount in any custody or contact dispute between parents.

Read More