Mc Naught & Co

Medical Malpractice


The undermentioned article is the interpretation of the law and the opinion of the writer and in no way constitutes legal advice pertaining to your particular matter. Please visit and contact our professional team for specialized legal service.


In the President’s address on 09 April 2020 regarding the extension of the lockdown, a disturbing note was South Africa’s shortage of medical protective equipment for healthcare workers to help prevent the spread of the Coronavirus. Thus, making it high risk for our “army” who are on the forefront of this pandemic, fighting against an invisible enemy. This sort of situation places additional pressure on an already strained healthcare system and on professionals working long hours.


There has been a significant increase in the number of medical negligence cases in South Africa, particularly in Gauteng. Whilst, the common cases are mainly maternity, obstetric and orthopaedic claims, with our healthcare system currently under great strain and medical practitioners under immense pressure, we must take extra precaution and be more mindful when receiving treatment not just for Covid-19 but of any kind.


Medical negligence is caused when a medical practitioner and/or healthcare worker does not exercise the necessary and reasonable standard of care in the treatment of a patient, thereby resulting in an injury or a medical side effect. To assess whether you have a medical negligence claim, take note of the following:

1. The harm and/or injury suffered must be a direct cause of the practitioner’s actions or lack thereof;
2. The reasonable standard of care in receiving treatment was not excercised. In other words, “was the conduct below the standard of a reasonably competition practitioner
in his field? – if the “error” is one that a reasonably competent practitioner would have made, it will not amount to negligence” (Castell v De Greef). This is determined by a specialist.
3. There must a doctor-patient relationship in order for a claim. The doctor must be directly responsible for medically treating the patient.


Furthermore, a medical practitioner cannot be held liable for unforeseen side effects from unavoidable treatment.


In a healthcare system under immense pressure with our healthcare professionals sometimes working under extremely trying circumstances, unfortunate mistakes may occur. Not all such mistakes amount to medical negligence however.


The above are the basic elements to assess medical negligence, however same is not an exhaustive list. It is advisable to keep a coherent list of the sequence of events, advices rendered, side effects, and your medical records to enable you to obtain a comprehensive opinion on whether or not you should proceed with a claim in the event of an issue.

Contact one of our
professionals to advise and assist in such an event.

Share this article
Read our
most recent!
Wrongfulness and Legal Duty

Wrongfulness and Legal Duty

A recent judgment was passed in the Supreme Court of Appeal, the facts to the case itself are indeed interesting, especially for pet owners. The claimant in the matter, arranged with her friends for a weekend of leisure at the Harmony Park Resort, a day camp (the Day Camp) situated at Strand in the Western Cape. The Day Camp was a public facility under the control of the defendant, the City of Cape Town.

Read More
SA Divorces up by 20% since Lockdown Level 4

SA Divorces up by 20% since Lockdown Level 4

Courts around South Africa are battling a surprising divorce backlog. This is such a problem that a plan to fast-track annulments of more than 11 000 failed marriages in Limpopo alone has had to be devised. Limpopo is not the only province with a heavy load of divorce applications. The South Gauteng High Court heard 33 unopposed divorces last Friday.

Read More
Are Mothers’ rights more equal than Fathers’?

Are Mothers’ rights more equal than Fathers’?

Parental Responsibilities and Rights are under the spotlight today. The Children’s Act 38 of 2005 has attempted to focus our society and courts’ attention on the interests of the child which are paramount in any custody or contact dispute between parents.

Read More